2024
Hays Marionneaux - Grinnell College
Preston Sentino - Centenary College
William Mondello - LSU Eunice (Soccer)
2022
LeDamion Dixon - Mississippi College
2021
Ethan Hames - Mississippi College
Eric Thibodeaux - Henderson State University
2019
Chris Sehring - Delta State University
CJ Casma - Sterling College
2018
Chase Fisher - East Texas Baptist University
2017
Treylan Sibley - Southern Arkansas University
Nathan Scott - Nicholls State University
2016
Jeremiah Campbell - Mississippi College
Clarence McGarner - Louisiana College
Beau Morris - Southern Methodist University
2015
Matthew Butler - Texas Southern University
2014
Michael Ostrom - Louisiana State University
2013
Brandon Fields - Fordham University
Blake Hartmann - Nicholls State University
Corey Holmes - Louisiana College
CJ Okpalobi - Nicholls State University
Alex Ruch - Millsaps College
2012
Josh Ambeau - Ava Maria University
Dash Duncan - Nicholls State University
Chase Krause - Florida Institute of Technology
2011
CJ Patton - Nicholls State University
2010
Ryan Bruno - Nicholls State University
Jeremy Meyers - Southeastern Louisiana University
Nicholas Scelfo - Nicholls State University
Ryan Zeller - Nicholls State University
2009
Julius Warmsley - Tulane University and Tennessee Titans, NFL
John Roberts, JR - Southeastern Louisiana University
2008
Lindsey Leavoy - Southeastern Louisiana University
Evan Ruiz - University of Louisiana, Lafayette
2005
Chad Davis - McNeese State University
Austin Williams - Nicholls State University
2004
Chris Keagle - Louisiana Tech University
2003
Zachary Leger - University of Louisiana, Lafayette
Benjamin Robichaux - Millsaps College
2002
Greg Theriot - Nicholls State University
Audie Williams - Nicholls State University
Blake Lorio - Nicholls State University
Turk Olsen - University of Louisiana, Lafayette
Caleb Prejean - Benedictine College